Robert Aldrich was a brave man, braver than director Edmund Goulding, who, in 1943, when faced with the prospect of directing the feuding, intransigent, cantankerous duo of Miriam Hopkins and Bette Davis a second time, faked a heart attack. Aldrich, however, had done well by Baby Jane. It made sense to do a sequel with the same stars before his imitators ran the cycle into the ground. Farrell, Baby Jane's author, had come up with another saga of hate, What Ever Happened to Cousin Charlotte? Crawford agreed to costar in it with Davis, but, even though Davis would be playing Charlotte, Crawford wanted top billing. She also expected $50,000 and twenty-five percent of net profits. Davis screamed at Aldrich when she heard this and demanded $200,000 and fifteen percent.
"That is the same amount I'm getting for producing and directing," he fumed. "That makes us partners on this picture." (Ibid, 337)
"Partners," said Davis, puffing on her fifty-first cigarette of the day. "All the way down the line. I will hold you to that." Twentieth Century-Fox agreed to Aldrich's budget of $1.3 million, part of which went to paying off Farrell and hiring Heller to write the script. Davis soon threatened to quit, complaining that Aldrich had not yet changed the "cheap" title or hired a cinematographer. To placate her, Aldrich hired the painterly Joseph Biroc, raised Davis's percentage to twenty-five percent, and gave her equal billing with Crawford in "alphabetical order." And the film would now be called Hush ... Hush, Sweet Charlotte. It was the story of another aging recluse, Charlotte, who asks her cousin Miriam to help her save the old family mansion from demolition by the Louisiana Highway Commission. Charlotte fears that the building will yield evidence that her father killed her married lover, John, in 1927. Charlotte is haunted by dreams and hallucinations of the unsolved murder, in which a mystery killer surprised John and then chopped off his hand and his head.
Rehearsals and wardrobe tests began at Twentieth in mid-May 1964, postponed for a month because Crawford could not get out of her Pepsi commitments. The turf tiffs began immediately. Davis had a closed set for her wardrobe tests. Crawford wanted to see what Davis would be wearing.
"What does it matter, Joan? I am going to be a mess and you are going to be your usual gorgeous self." (Ibid, 339)
"Dear Bette," said Crawford with a million-dollar smile. "Bless you."
The Sweet Charlotte company flew to Baton Rouge on May 31, but Crawford made the mistake of flying in a few days late. Davis was taking her status as Aldrich's partner quite seriously. She had already ingratiated herself with the crew. When Crawford landed, there was inexplicably no one at the airport to meet her. Her lodging arrangements were also confused. When she arrived at the location, the Houmas House Plantation in Burnside, Louisiana, it was apparent that Davis was relishing her role as unofficial producer. Crawford, sensing that she was at a disadvantage, decided to keep out of her way and stayed with her entourage.
"Bette lets her hair down," wrote gossip columnist Sheilah Graham, "but Joan surrounds herself with the aura of a great of yesterday. Times have changed and she doesn't seem to realize that." (Ibid, 343) Crawford did realize that she had to put on a good face, so she made attempts to win Davis over. "Miss Crawford always says ‘Good morning,' when she walks onto the set," wrote columnist Lily May Caldwell. "Miss Davis seldom answers her." (Ibid, 345) Davis usually walked away, swigging a Coke and snickering to anyone who would listen: "Old ‘Bless you' is at it again." Snubbed, Crawford went back to her trailer and poured herself a Pepsi (with Smirnoff). "Crawford obviously wants to clear the air," wrote Len Baxter of Motion Picture magazine. "But Davis is not able to kiss and make up. She doesn't know how to say ‘I'm sorry,' and Crawford doesn't feel that she has anything to be sorry for." (Ibid, 346) Davis certainly thought so, according to her secretary, Vik Greenfield. "After the business with the Oscar, this was war."
Bit by bit, hour by hour, Davis saw to it that Crawford was undermined and ostracized. "Bette was a formidable presence on the set," said Aldrich regular Gary. (Ibid, 348) "She and Aldrich were very tight," recalled unit publicist Harry Mines. "She was always by his elbow." Aldrich's son, Bill, was again working with the two legends. "Bette was something else," he recalled. "She worked the company, the crew. She was a very strong lady who was still carrying on a one-way feud with Crawford." (Ibid, 349) Davis began to sit in front of the camera, watching Crawford do her scenes, a highly unprofessional situation for Aldrich to allow. Just as before, when Crawford would do a line reading for a last rehearsal, Davis would turn to Aldrich. "My God! Is that the way she's going to play it?" (Thomas, Joan Crawford, 224) Crawford was gracious about the unsolicited opinions, but even the most casual observer could see that her armor was cracking. She spent more and more time in her trailer.
"[Hush ... Hush, Sweet Charlotte] couldn't have been more the opposite than its predecessor," recalled Aldrich. "A terribly hostile atmosphere prevailed." (Higham, The Celluloid Muse, 40) Davis was now making remarks about Crawford's advanced age to reporters. Crawford was sixty and looking quite presentable. Davis was fifty-six and showing the effects of years of nicotine addiction. The clincher came for Crawford when she phoned Aldrich at his hotel room one night to set things straight. She started talking about the script, then heard a familiar voice in the background. "It was Miss Davis," she recalled. Whether Davis was sleeping with Aldrich or not, she had his ear; Crawford was in trouble. "I'd looked forward to working with Bette again," Crawford said later. "I had no idea of the extent of her hate and that she planned to destroy me." (Considine, Bette and Joan, 360)
The coup de grace was delivered on June 12, the last day of location shooting. While Crawford napped in her trailer, waiting to be called back to the set, the company pitched its tents and drove to the airport without notifying her or arranging for her transportation. She had to book her own flight on a commercial airline. For two weeks, Crawford had been going back and forth between her fifty-five-degree trailer and the hot, humid outdoor location. Isolated from the company because of Davis's machinations, she stayed in her hotel room at night and drank. The climate, the alcohol, and the stress took their toll. On Saturday, June 13, she checked into Cedars of Lebanon Hospital with an "upper respiratory virus infection." (Thomas, Joan Crawford, 225) On a visit with Crawford, Hopper noted that she had her script with her in the hospital bed. She was making changes in it. When Aldrich and Davis refused her changes longer, more glamorous scenes her illness turned into pneumonia.
A month later, she was well enough to report to work at Twentieth Century-Fox. Davis was standing by the camera again. Crawford was shooting a scene with Joseph Cotten. Davis interrupted. "I am cutting some dialogue," she informed Crawford, who didn't fight back but soon started missing work. Aldrich tried to force Crawford's hand with an examination by a specialist. Crawford's doctor sent her back to the hospital in an ambulance. "At that stage," said Aldrich, "the insurance company offered us the alternatives of finding a replacement for Miss Crawford within two weeks or scrapping the picture." (Higham, Celluloid Muse, 31)
Crawford was well aware of what had happened to Marilyn Monroe and George Cukor two years earlier on Something's Got to Give. "Twentieth had closed down my last movie because no actress wanted to take over for Monroe," said Cukor. "The picture was [insured] and I think Joan figured they would do the same thing for her." (COnsidine, Bette and Joan, 358) Aldrich took the kinder view. "There's no doubt in the world that Crawford was sick, seriously sick," he said. "If she'd been faking, either the insurance company would never have paid the claim or she would never have been insurable again. Insurance companies here are terribly tough, and there's no such thing as a made-up ailment that they pay off on." If Cukor was correct, Crawford may have taken the precaution of warning Stanwyck and Young to decline the role because when Aldrich approached them, they both said no. Crawford no doubt knew that if the studio closed down Hush ... Hush, Sweet Charlotte, Davis would lose: (1) the role of Charlotte; (2) more than $100,000 in pending salary; and (3) her percentage points of the film's profits. Whether Crawford was faking or not, the result would be the same: Crawford would defeat Davis.
While Crawford lay in the hospital and recovered or faked, depending on what one believed Aldrich looked at his options and decided to continue. He asked vice-president in charge of production Richard Zanuck if he would approve an additional $285,000. Zanuck said yes and Aldrich began shopping for a new Miriam. "Davis had star approval," said Aldrich. "Until then it had been academic because she had approved Crawford, but it now became vitally important." Before Davis could veto her, Hepburn said no. Aldrich suggested Vivien Leigh and warned that Davis had better make up her mind quickly. "I will not do Charlotte with the very British Miss Leigh," Davis wrote Aldrich. "For Twentieth to suspend me is nonsense. . . . Why go from the frying pan to the fire? This is what you would be doing. Trust my lousy female instincts. They have been known to be right every now and then." Leigh had her own ideas. "No, thank you," said Leigh to a Twentieth Century-Fox executive. "I could just about stand looking at Joan Crawford's face at six o'clock in the morning, but not at Bette Davis's." (Considine, Bette and Joan,359)
Aldrich's next candidate was de Havilland, who was traveling. "[Davis] tried to persuade Olivia to do the part, helped me talk to her on the phone," said Aldrich. "No good. So I went off to Switzerland to try to convince de Havilland in person. It was terribly difficult. I'm not quite sure why, but I think it has to do with Miss de Havilland's opinion of what her image is vis à vis what it may be." (Higham, Celluloid Muse, 41) Sitting on a mountaintop, they went back and forth about Miriam's character.
"In the first script she was written as rude," said de Havilland. "That's what threw me and put me off frightfully. She depressed me because she was so wicked."
"You mean the ambivalence, the counterpoint, the duality don't interest you?" Aldrich asked her.
"That's just what she doesn't have," de Havilland replied. "She's all one color black, solid black. If one thing were changed her rudeness if you take that away and give her the opposite exquisite manners, exquisite courtesy then she becomes really dangerous . . . . It's always the charming ones of evil intent who are the dangerous ones." (De Havilland, "Come Out," 21)
Aldrich offered de Havilland $100,000. She accepted, and Aldrich called Davis with the news. She was pleased. Then he asked her to keep it quiet for two days until he could give Crawford's lawyer formal notice. He might as well have saved his breath. Davis immediately alerted her press agent, who made surreptitious calls to the Hollywood press. Crawford was in her hospital bed when she heard the news on the radio. "Aldrich knew where to long-distance me all over the world when he needed me," she told reporters. "But he made no effort to reach me here to alert me that he had signed Olivia. He let me hear it for the first time in the radio release. And, frankly, I think it stinks." (Stine, Mother Goddam, 310)
Of course, the same question was in everyone's mind. How can nice Olivia be as mean to Bette as Joan would have been in the part of Miriam? After working with Davis in a 1942 John Huston film called In This Our Life, de Havilland knew what to expect. And if she had forgotten, Davis reminded her. De Havilland gave a surprising performance, especially in the scenes where she berates, threatens, and slaps Davis. The roughest scene was the one in which Davis accidentally kills Joseph Cotten. "You wretched idiot!" groans de Havilland. Davis begs her to help bury the body. When Davis starts to lose her nerve, de Havilland turns into a growling virago. "Damn you. Now will you shut your mouth!" Her voice lowers. "You'll do as I tell you. And if I tell you to lie, you'll do that too." Her voice becomes a snarling whisper. "I'm never going to suffer for you again. Not ever. Do you understand?" With de Havilland as Miriam, Aldrich had created yet another horror queen. Could Crawford have summoned up the monstrous rage that De Havilland did? Probably. But to finish that movie might have killed her. Or Davis. Or both of them. It finally put Aldrich in the hospital with exhaustion.
The film hit the theaters on Christmas Eve 1964 and Time said:
Hush ... Hush, Sweet Charlotte is a gruesome slice of shock therapy that, pointedly, is not a sequel to What Ever Happened to Baby Jane? The two films are blood relatives, as producer-director Robert Aldrich well knows, but Charlotte has a worse play, more gore, and enough bitchery to fill several outrageous freak shows. The choicest holdover from Jane is Bette Davis, unabashedly securing her clawhold as Hollywood's grande dame ghoul. (Ringgold, Films of Bette Davis, 186)