The author is a fine writer at his best in discussing the more gripping Wilder films like Double Indemnity and Some Like It Hot. He nicely captures the former's Phyllis Diedrichson character (Barbara Stanwyck) by calling her the rhinestone tarantula at the center of a spangled web, and neatly summarizes the complex relationship of Walter Neff (Fred Macmurray) and Barton Keyes (Edward G. Robinson): That Neff loves this man is not surprising; one loves what one lacks. Not that the book is simply a series of well-turned phrases; the author's analysis of Marilyn Monroe's Sugar character in Some Like It Hot is equal parts insight and pathos.
Adding to the book's research value this is arguably the one monograph on Wilder that should be on every cineaste's shelf are the author's authoritative discussions of the literary sources of the films, assessments of their commercial and critical success or failure, and a refreshing recognition of the contributions of Wilder's collaborators from the obvious (I. A. L. Diamond and Charles Brackett) to the less so (Miklos Rosza's score for The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes).
A Talent for Trouble: The Life of Hollywood's Most Acclaimed Director, William Wyler. New York: Da Capo Press (a division of Plenum Publishing), 1997 (updated edition). $16.95, ISBN 0-306-80798-X. Trade paperback, 517pp. To order, contact Da Capo Press at 1-800-321-0050 or go to a damned bookstore.
The word sonofabitch may be the single most common description of movie directors, particularly by abused, disgruntled actors. Fritz Lang and Otto Preminger immediately come to mind in this regard, but even allegedly gentle directors like Sirk have been so labeled (by Gloria Talbot, from All That Heaven Allows). William Wyler was one of the major Hollywood sonofabitches, according to Jan Herman's William Wyler: A Talent for Trouble, but also one of its keenest talents whose sometimes noxious ways paid off in screen performances that continue to resonate decades later.
This big, solidly researched critical bio (500+ pages) explores Wyler's personal history and career with intelligence and depth, along the way painting a witty, incisive portrait of a Hollywood that, for better or worse, is long gone. Wyler's intellectual intransigence, bullying ways, his hatred of the dishonesty of Hollywood, along with personal tragedies and triumphs are all thoroughly detailed. Buffs will most appreciate Herman's strong discussion of the circumstances of the making of the films, though some of the critical assessments seem misjudged e.g., writing off one of Wyler's best, Dead End, as dated and stagebound. (A few minutes with Claire Trevor's riveting consumptive whore or the East Side Kids' scorchingly sarcastic brats jettisons such notions.)
Wyler's relationship with actors is what's most intriguing about him driving his style and forming his cinematic legacy and the book goes into considerable detail there. Surprisingly, some actors like Gregory Peck actually appreciated his authoritarian methods, happy with a director whose artistry demanded endless takes to get the effect he wanted. On the other hand, Sylvia Sidney disliked him intensely, not least because of what would now be called his sexual harassment of her. Still, under Wyler's direction in Dead End, she gave one of her greatest performances. Wyler's ability with actors, the book shows, won over even hard-line anti-Wylerites like Andrew Sarris, who praised the extraordinary performances in one of the later works, The Collector. Wyler's well-known affair with and unceremonious dumping of Bette Davis is thoroughly examined, but again, as the author reminds us, with Wyler the performances were all, and they have outlasted such peccadilloes.
Other important titles that Da Capo has returned to print include Lotte Eisner's Fritz Lang, Peter Cowie's The Cinema of Orson Welles, Parker Tyler's Screening the Sexes, Sarris's The American Cinema, and David Robinson's Chaplin: His Life and Art. Look for 'em!
May 1998 | Issue 21
Copyright © 1998 by Gary Morris
ALSO: More book reviews
home | current
issue |
archives | search | about
us | contact | donate | blog | links